1. Inspect for Common Signs of Damage

Check the following areas on your brickface siding:

• Cracks and Chips: Look for cracks, chips, or missing pieces in the brickface surface.

• Loose or Bulging Areas: Tap gently—if you hear a hollow sound or see areas pulling away from the wall, this indicates adhesion failure.

• Water Stains and Efflorescence: White, chalky deposits or dark stains signal moisture issues, which can undermine the siding and underlying structure.

• Discoloration or Fading: Uneven color or fading can be a sign of weathering, age, or water damage.

• Spalling: If the surface is flaking, crumbling, or “shedding,” the coating is failing and needs prompt attention.

• Mold or Mildew: Green, black, or brown spots, especially near joints or at the base, point to trapped moisture behind the siding.

2. Assess the Severity and Extent

• Small, Localized Issues:
  Minor cracks, chips, or limited surface damage can often be repaired. Re-tinting, patching, or re-coating may be all that’s needed.

• Widespread or Structural Damage:
  If you notice large sections pulling away, extensive cracking, deep water stains, or evidence of moisture inside the home, a full replacement—or at least large-scale remediation—may be necessary.

• Persistent Moisture Problems:
  If leaks or efflorescence return after repairs, the underlying water barrier may be compromised, and replacement is usually the best long-term solution.

3. Evaluate the Age and Maintenance History

• Older Siding (15+ years) with Repeated Issues:
  Siding nearing the end of its lifespan and showing repeated problems may be more reliably replaced.

• Recently Damaged, Otherwise Healthy:
  Repair may be best for recent or accidental damage on newer, well-maintained siding.

4. Consider Professional Assessment

If you’re unsure, an experienced siding professional can:

• Perform a thorough inspection

• Use moisture meters and probing to check for hidden issues

• Recommend targeted repair or full replacement based on findings